Fitting An Ellipse To A Set Of Data Points In Python

I have a 2D points (x,y), and I want to fit the ellipse using this post fit a ellipse in Python given a set of points xi=(xi,yi) But my result is axes = [ 0.93209407 nan] since i

Solution 1:

I think there is a mistake in the code.

I've found a few other questions (1, 2) regarding the fitting of an ellipse to a set of data points and they all use the same piece of code from here.

In doing the fitting:

def fitEllipse(x,y):
    x = x[:,np.newaxis]
    y = y[:,np.newaxis]
    D =  np.hstack((x*x, x*y, y*y, x, y, np.ones_like(x)))
    S = np.dot(D.T,D)
    C = np.zeros([6,6])
    C[0,2] = C[2,0] = 2; C[1,1] = -1
    E, V =  eig(np.dot(inv(S), C))
    n = np.argmax(np.abs(E))
    a = V[:,n]
    return a

The eigenvalue-eigenvector pair is chosen using the max absolute eigenvalue from E. However, in the original paper by Fitzgibbon, Pilu and Fischer in Fitzgibbon, A.W., Pilu, M., and Fischer R.B., Direct least squares fitting of ellipses, 1996:

We note that the solution of the eigensystem (6) gives 6 eigenvalue-eigenvector pairs (\lambda_i, u_i). Each of these pairs gives rise to a local minimum if the term under the square root in (8) is positive. In general, S is positive definite, so the denominator u_i^T S u_i is positive for all u_i. Therefore the square root exists if \lambda_i>0.

They further proved that there is only one positive eigenvalue solution, which makes it also the maximum among the 6 eigenvalues.

However, finding this maximum by np.argmax(np.abs(E)) makes it possible to choose an originally negative value, thus giving the wrong answer.

I've found one specific example that demonstrates the problem. Below is an array of (x,y) coordinates:

159.598484728,45.0095214844
157.713012695,45.7333132048
156.163772773,46.6618041992
154.15536499,47.3460795985
152.140428382,48.0673522949
150.045213426,48.4620666504
148.194464489,47.868850708
145.55770874,47.6356541717
144.0753479,48.6449446276
144.19475866,50.200668335
144.668289185,51.7677851197
145.55770874,53.033584871
147.632995605,53.5380252111
149.411834717,52.9216872972
150.568775939,51.6947631836
151.23727763,50.390045166
153.265945435,49.7778711963
155.934188843,49.8835742956
158.305969238,49.5737389294
160.677734375,49.1867334409
162.675320529,48.4620666504
163.938919067,47.4491661856
163.550473712,45.841796875
161.863616943,45.0017850512

Save that as 'contour_ellipse.txt' and run this script will give the figure shown below:

import numpy
import pandas as pd
from matplotlib.patches import Ellipse

def fitEllipse(cont,method):

    x=cont[:,0]
    y=cont[:,1]

    x=x[:,None]
    y=y[:,None]

    D=numpy.hstack([x*x,x*y,y*y,x,y,numpy.ones(x.shape)])
    S=numpy.dot(D.T,D)
    C=numpy.zeros([6,6])
    C[0,2]=C[2,0]=2
    C[1,1]=-1
    E,V=numpy.linalg.eig(numpy.dot(numpy.linalg.inv(S),C))

    if method==1:
        n=numpy.argmax(numpy.abs(E))
    else:
        n=numpy.argmax(E)
    a=V[:,n]

    #-------------------Fit ellipse-------------------
    b,c,d,f,g,a=a[1]/2., a[2], a[3]/2., a[4]/2., a[5], a[0]
    num=b*b-a*c
    cx=(c*d-b*f)/num
    cy=(a*f-b*d)/num

    angle=0.5*numpy.arctan(2*b/(a-c))*180/numpy.pi
    up = 2*(a*f*f+c*d*d+g*b*b-2*b*d*f-a*c*g)
    down1=(b*b-a*c)*( (c-a)*numpy.sqrt(1+4*b*b/((a-c)*(a-c)))-(c+a))
    down2=(b*b-a*c)*( (a-c)*numpy.sqrt(1+4*b*b/((a-c)*(a-c)))-(c+a))
    a=numpy.sqrt(abs(up/down1))
    b=numpy.sqrt(abs(up/down2))

    #---------------------Get path---------------------
    ell=Ellipse((cx,cy),a*2.,b*2.,angle)
    ell_coord=ell.get_verts()

    params=[cx,cy,a,b,angle]

    return params,ell_coord

def plotConts(contour_list):
    '''Plot a list of contours'''
    import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
    fig=plt.figure()
    ax2=fig.add_subplot(111)
    for ii,cii in enumerate(contour_list):
        x=cii[:,0]
        y=cii[:,1]
        ax2.plot(x,y,'-')
    plt.show(block=False)

#-------------------Read in data-------------------
df=pd.read_csv('contour_ellipse.txt')
data=numpy.array(df)

params1,ell1=fitEllipse(data,1)
params2,ell2=fitEllipse(data,2)

plotConts([data,ell1,ell2])

The small ellipse is the original code, the green one is the fixed one.

This mistake won't show up every time because many times the maximum is also the maximum of absolute values.

A few confusing things:

If you look at Fitzgibbon's paper from here: http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~mdailey/Face-Coord/ellipse-specific-fitting.pdf, they said

Since the eigenvalues of C are {-2, -1, 2, 0, 0, 0}, from Lemma 1 we have that (8) has exactly one positive eigenvalue \lambda_i < 0

I think this is a typo and the < should be >.

Another paper that talks about this (https://github.com/bdhammel/least-squares-ellipse-fitting/blob/master/media/WSCG98.pdf), they said

we are looking for the eigenvector a_k corresponding to the minimal positive eigenvalue \labmda_k

It's confusing as there should be only one positive.

And finally it can also give you problem if the number of data to fit is less than 6, the number of parameters.

Solution 2:

I would recommend using scikit-image.

It has an ellipse fitting function EllipseModel which implements Halir, R.; Flusser, J. “Numerically stable direct least squares fitting of ellipses”. In Proc. 6th International Conference in Central Europe on Computer Graphics and Visualization. WSCG (Vol. 98, pp. 125-132).

An example using the points you define above:

import numpy as np
from skimage.measure import EllipseModel
from matplotlib.patches import Ellipse
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

points = [(0,3),(1,2),(1,7),(2,2),(2,4),(2,5),(2,6),(2,14),(3,4),(4,4),(5,5),(5,14),(6,4),(7,3),(7,7),(8,10),(9,1),(9,8),(9,9),(10,1),(10,2),(10,12),(11,0),(11, 7),(12,7),(12,11),(12,12),(13,6),(13,8),(13,12),(14,4),(14,5),(14,10),(14,13)]

a_points = np.array(points)
x = a_points[:, 0]
y = a_points[:, 1]

ell = EllipseModel()
ell.estimate(a_points)

xc, yc, a, b, theta = ell.params

print("center = ",  (xc, yc))
print("angle of rotation = ",  theta)
print("axes = ", (a,b))

fig, axs = plt.subplots(2, 1, sharex=True, sharey=True)
axs[0].scatter(x,y)

axs[1].scatter(x, y)
axs[1].scatter(xc, yc, color='red', s=100)
axs[1].set_xlim(x.min(), x.max())
axs[1].set_ylim(y.min(), y.max())

ell_patch = Ellipse((xc, yc), 2*a, 2*b, theta*180/np.pi, edgecolor='red', facecolor='none')

axs[1].add_patch(ell_patch)
plt.show()

Returns:

center =  (7.290242506300351, 7.317565035114109)
angle of rotation =  2.1516086051307814
axes =  (5.956065316845365, 6.195071281072721)